New York’s Delivery Protection Act Faces Growing Legal and Political Opposition
As a City Council vote approaches, opponents are combining federal and state legal arguments with concerns over the potential impact on minority-owned delivery businesses and workers across New York City.

As the Delivery Protection Act inches closer to a possible vote before the end of the year, opposition to New York City’s proposed legislation is growing. The measure could still be heavily modified before it gets to the City Council, but opponents have intensified their campaign to stop the measure as it now stands.
The resistance has been growing over the last few weeks with protests outside City Hall, a higher profile in the media, and an ad campaign that is becoming more and more visible to New Yorkers. The New York Post has also given a high-profile stage to critics of the proposed legislation, publishing a series of reports questioning its potential impact for the city’s delivery industry.
The newspaper’s latest coverage said Amazon (NASDAQ: AMZN) has warned that implementing the legislation without amendments could increase delivery costs by as much as $5 a package in New York City. The company maintains these additional costs could eventually be passed on to consumers.
Council Speaker Julie Menin took to X to respond to the claims, noting the final legislative language remains a key issue as negotiations continue. She is seen as a major player in shaping the bill before the vote.
The debate is also producing a strange political alignment. Amazon is often the company that progressive politicians feel compelled to attack, but there are now a number of arguments against the proposed legislation coming from delivery contractors whose positions seem closer to traditional labor and social justice concerns.
While Amazon is the most affected company by the proposal, other large operators like FedEx (NYSE: FDX) would also suffer serious consequences.
A strange political alliance around Amazon
In the past, Amazon has been heavily criticized by leading figures on the American political left.
Sen. Bernie Sanders has repeatedly criticized what he calls the company’s corporate greed. Former Vise President and Democratic presidential contender Kamala Harris wants Amazon and other big tech companies to be regulated more heavily. Democratic Socialist Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez was also viewed as a key player in the opposition that eventually led Amazon to abandon its original plans for a second headquarters in New York City. Instead, the company picked Northern Virginia.
The political opposition has not died out. Democratic Socialist New York City Mayor Zohran Mamdani has been an outspoken supporter of the Delivery Protection Act.
But the pushback against the legislation is now coming from arguments and demonstrations not usually seen from groups defending Amazon’s business model.
For the past two weeks, the New York Delivers Coalition, made up of direct service providers (DSPs), has been holding a demonstration on the steps of New York City Hall. The coalition also planned a protest Thursday outside the district headquarters of Council Member Tiffany Caban, who introduced the Delivery Protection Act last year.
The tone of these demonstrations has been noticed. At the City Hall rally, one speaker led participants in chanting “No Justice, No Peace!”, a slogan long associated with civil rights activist Reverend Al Sharpton and protests organized by progressive movements.
The racial aspect of the opposition was also a big issue at the coalition’s latest media conference. The meeting was nominally called to explore the legal vulnerabilities that opponents say are embedded in the proposed legislation, but discussions of race and the makeup of the delivery workforce took up considerably more time than did the legal arguments. The same concerns were raised in the November 12 demonstration at City Hall.
“Members of the City Council should consider what the possible consequences will be for business owners and their employees,” said Derek Sells, chairman of the Cochran Law Firm and outside legal counsel to New York Delivers.
He then turned to the make-up of the sector’s demographics, detailing the possible effect of the legislation as a major concern for minority communities.
Minority workers and business owners at the centre of the debate
Citing research conducted by consulting firm AKRF, Sells said that 80% of last-mile delivery workers are people of colour, while 88% live in New York City. According to the same research, 49% reside in communities officially designated by New York State as disadvantaged.
The study also estimates that between 3,000 and more than 10,000 workers could lose their jobs if the legislation is implemented, according to Sells.
Mark Morial, former mayor of New Orleans and current chief executive officer of the National Urban League, also challenged the rationale behind the proposed law during the media conference.
He questioned why a city that considers itself progressive would support legislation that, in his view, could undermine businesses owned by people standing alongside him, as well as numerous other companies, without guaranteeing employment protection or compensation for affected workers.
The discussion largely centred on these economic and social consequences during the approximately 30-minute event, with detailed examination of the potential legal challenges receiving comparatively limited attention.
A nine-page legal challenge outlines three main objections
A more comprehensive examination of the legal opposition appears in a nine-page letter sent by Sells to City Council Speaker Julie Menin.
The letter identifies several potential conflicts between the Delivery Protection Act, existing New York legislation and federal law.
In its original form, the proposal establishes four principal requirements for delivery companies operating within New York City.
First, delivery operators would need to obtain a licence to conduct business in the city. Second, they would be prohibited from employing subcontractors. Third, companies would have to offer employment to workers displaced by the elimination of subcontracting arrangements. Finally, their operating licences could be revoked if they breached any of a number of regulatory requirements.
The proposal's original wording could have particularly significant implications for Amazon.
The company currently operates through approximately 100 Delivery Service Partners (DSPs) in New York City. Under the proposed prohibition on subcontracting, Amazon could be required to acquire these businesses and directly employ their delivery workers, replacing the existing arrangements under which drivers work for independent DSPs.
However, the legislation is expected to undergo substantial revisions before any final vote.
The Teamsters union has strongly supported the Delivery Protection Act. Its backing reflects the union's broader campaign to organise Amazon workers and secure collective bargaining rights.
The union has already achieved a recent breakthrough in Canada, where Amazon workers obtained a contract, following a lengthy and difficult organising campaign elsewhere in New York City. A separate effort to unionise DSP delivery drivers has proved even more challenging.
Against this background, Sells' letter identifies three broad legal grounds on which he believes the proposed legislation could be challenged.
The first concerns federal restrictions on the authority of state and local governments to regulate delivery operations.
According to the letter, federal law limits the ability of cities and states to determine how delivery companies structure their services, organise their operations and select the businesses or individuals responsible for carrying out deliveries.
The second objection relates to existing New York State legislation.
Sells argues that state law already establishes the circumstances under which delivery drivers must be classified as employees and when companies are permitted to use independent businesses to perform delivery services.
In his view, Intro 518, another designation for the Delivery Protection Act, would prohibit commercial arrangements that are already permitted and regulated under state law.
The third argument concerns the geographical reach of the proposed legislation.
Sells maintains that New York City cannot override federal or state law and questions whether the city has the authority to regulate companies and drivers operating beyond its five boroughs.
The letter specifically refers to facilities located in New Jersey, Westchester and Long Island, arguing that the legislation could affect businesses outside the city's jurisdiction and potentially interfere with interstate commerce.
Minority communities could suffer most from legal uncertainty
The letter also revisits the demographic issues raised during the public demonstrations, notably the representation of people of color among DSP employees and business owners.
These arguments may have some political weight, but as direct legal grounds for challenging the legislation they are less clear-cut.
Sells, however, links the demographic issue to the possible effects of prolonged litigation.
“Passage of the Delivery Protection Act could lead to years of costly litigation as courts decide whether the legislation is legally tenable, creating uncertainty for businesses and employees alike,” he says.
In his letter, he contended the proposed law could end up being struck down after businesses had already spent a lot of money and workers were left without the protections the City Council wanted to put in place.
The letter argues the consequences would disproportionately impact Black, Latino, immigrant and outer-borough communities.
It also warns that smaller businesses that employ these workers could be forced to close while the litigation plays out, leaving employees potentially without their current jobs or the new protections promised in the legislation.
Opposition puts federal aviation law in spotlight
One of the more significant legal arguments in Sells’ letter relates to the Federal Aviation Administration Authorization Act (F4A).
The name has an aviation connection, but the legislation includes an important provision limiting state and local government actions affecting the price, route or service of certain transportation operations.
This provision has been at the heart of disputes concerning state regulation of transportation and independent contractors.
That was at the center of the now-resolved legal fight over California's AB5 independent contractor law. But more recently, the same federal law did not protect against broker liability in the Montgomery v. Caribe Transport II case.
In his letter, Sells cites federal court precedents where legislation addressing independent contractor classifications and hiring requirements was found to be in conflict with F4A.
He says the Delivery Protection Act goes even further than the measures explored in those earlier cases, making a legal challenge more likely.
Sells also expects supporters of the New York legislation to attempt to use F4A’s safety exception to back the bill.
That exception allows certain state actions, including tort-related actions, even if they might otherwise be deemed to affect transportation prices, routes or services.
But Sells questions whether that exception applies to the proposed limits on delivery companies.
He argues that the bill is about regulating the structure of companies, not the safety of cars and how they are operated.
In his letter he says: "A rule that determines the corporate identity of a driver's employer, and that prohibits an entire category of commercial relationships, is a matter of business organization, not vehicle safety.
A decisive stage for New York City's delivery sector
The opposition campaign is gaining momentum at a critical moment for the Delivery Protection Act.
With the possibility of amendments before a City Council vote expected before the end of the year, the debate is no longer limited to the question of how Amazon and other delivery companies should organise their workforces.
It has expanded into a broader confrontation involving federal regulatory authority, New York State employment law, the future of independent delivery contractors and the economic position of minority-owned businesses.
For supporters, the legislation represents an opportunity to strengthen worker protections and reshape employment conditions across the last-mile delivery industry.
For opponents, its potential consequences include higher delivery costs, the loss of thousands of jobs, the closure of smaller businesses and lengthy legal battles that could ultimately undermine the legislation itself.
The final wording of the proposal, and the position adopted by Council Speaker Julie Menin, will therefore be crucial in determining whether New York City moves forward with its proposed overhaul of the delivery sector.



