Who Controls Air Cargo Capacity? The Growing Power of Pilot Recruitment and Retention
As North American air cargo operators increasingly rely on outsourced aircraft capacity, the availability of qualified pilots is emerging as a decisive factor in network reliability, operational flexibility and long-term industry growth.

Air cargo capacity has traditionally been measured through fleet size, aircraft orders and the strength of airline networks. However, this approach no longer tells the whole story. Having aircraft available does not necessarily mean having the resources to operate them. In an increasingly complex cargo market, real capacity depends on three closely connected elements: aircraft availability, qualified flight crews and workforce stability.
Across North America, a growing proportion of cargo capacity is provided by operators that do not necessarily own the commercial relationships behind the freight they carry. ACMI and charter companies have become essential partners for integrators, e-commerce businesses and freight forwarders. Their ability to deliver reliable capacity, however, depends increasingly on their success in recruiting and retaining pilots.
This raises an important question for the industry: who actually controls the ability to expand air cargo operations?
The issue is becoming particularly relevant as major carriers face different labor conditions. The ongoing negotiations involving UPS and its pilots illustrate how workforce agreements can influence the operational and commercial future of an entire cargo network.
The Changing Structure of Air Cargo Capacity
For many years, the traditional airline model brought aircraft ownership, network management, commercial operations and workforce responsibilities under one corporate structure. Airlines purchased their fleets, recruited pilots, marketed their capacity and operated their networks independently.
That structure is gradually evolving into a more fragmented system, where the organizations controlling aircraft, selling cargo space and providing operational personnel are not necessarily the same.
Four separate dimensions now help explain how capacity is distributed across the industry:
Capacity Dimension | Key Question |
|---|---|
Aircraft Ownership | Who owns the asset? |
Commercial Ownership | Who sells the capacity? |
Operational Ownership | Who flies the aircraft? |
Labor Ownership | Who controls access to qualified crews? |
Amazon Air provides a clear example of this increasingly distributed model. Although Amazon controls the commercial use of its air network, much of the operational and labor responsibility is handled by third-party operators, including ABX Air, ATI, Alaska Airlines and Sun Country Airlines.
Consequently, the company controlling the commercial network is not necessarily the organization supplying the aircraft crews or managing their employment.
Atlas Air offers another illustration of this transformation. It has established itself as one of the world's most influential outsourced freighter operators, providing aircraft capacity to express carriers, freight forwarders, e-commerce networks and government customers.
Although individual customer relationships have evolved over time, Atlas Air's scale demonstrates the strategic importance of ACMI providers in North American and international cargo operations.
The same trend extends well beyond e-commerce. Integrators, freight forwarders, governments and passenger airlines increasingly obtain freighter capacity through ACMI agreements rather than purchasing and operating additional aircraft themselves.
Companies such as Atlas Air, Kalitta Air, ATI and ABX Air have therefore moved beyond their traditional role as supplementary service providers. They now represent important components of supply-chain resilience.
Why Pilot Availability Is Becoming a Strategic Asset
The growing importance of outsourced capacity has changed the way the industry should assess ownership and control.
While ACMI providers increasingly manage the operational delivery of additional aircraft capacity, their ability to make that capacity available depends heavily on labor economics.
Pilot compensation is consequently becoming a strategic factor in determining who controls cargo capacity across North America.
Owning an aircraft does not guarantee that it can be operated. Without sufficient qualified crews, even an available and technically serviceable freighter cannot contribute to the network.
This distinction is particularly important when comparing integrated carriers such as FedEx and UPS Airlines with ACMI and supplemental operators.
FedEx and UPS operate substantial owned freighter fleets supported by long-term employment structures and seniority-based agreements. By contrast, Atlas Air, Kalitta Air, ABX Air and other outsourced operators supply the additional flexibility required by integrators, e-commerce companies and freight forwarders during seasonal peaks, network expansions and new route launches.
However, differences in total compensation packages between these two groups are increasingly influencing pilot recruitment, employee retention and the overall resilience of the cargo industry.
Pilot Pay Is a Competitive Edge
Integrated carriers’ compensation is more than an employment expense. It’s an investment to provide long-term access to experienced flight crews.”
FedEx showed the way with the new agreement ratified by its pilots in June 2026. Once approved, the ALPA agreement calls for nearly 40% hourly pay increases, with 3% annual scheduled increases.
The package also included better retirement provisions, including improved pension elements for pilots with longer service, as well as substantial defined-contribution rates. These benefits accumulate to a long-term earnings premium from working at an integrated carrier.
The deal was struck after years of hard bargaining. Over that period, union officials drew attention to rising pilot attrition and increasing operational pressures, emphasizing the link between workforce stability and network performance.
UPS Airlines pilots, represented by the Independent Pilots Association (IPA), are still flying under the rates from their previous agreement. That contract was extended in 2022 and was amendable on Sept. 1, 2025, meaning it can be reopened for re-negotiation. Discussions are still in mediation.
Both FedEx and UPS have relatively stable domicile based flying arrangements, comprehensive benefits and clear progressions of seniority. These attributes are still appealing to pilots who want to build a long-term career.
Comparing 767 pilot hourly pay
The compensation gap becomes particularly apparent when comparing top hourly rates for Boeing 767 pilots under the current contracts.
Carrier | Top Rate Captain | Top Rate First Officer |
|---|---|---|
FedEx | $469.00 | $332.49 |
UPS | $401.00 | $284.00 |
ABX Air* | $314.14 | $212.26 |
Atlas Air | $315.78 | $214.73 |
ATI* | $314.14 | $212.26 |
Sources: Carriers, unions and vectorstohired.com.
ABX Air and ATI are subsidiaries of Air Transport Services Group (ATSG), but are represented by separate unions and operate under separate collective bargaining agreements. Sources: Carriers, unions and vectorstohired.com.
ACMI providers face a different economic equation. They must remain competitive in the labor market while maintaining the cost advantages that make outsourced aircraft capacity attractive to customers.
As a result, their highest compensation rates are generally lower than those offered by integrated carriers.
Nevertheless, first-year first-officer salaries at ACMI operators can remain competitive within the cargo sector. During periods of expansion, pilots may also benefit from faster upgrade opportunities.
The overall employment package, however, often differs considerably. Retirement contributions tend to be less generous, schedules can be more variable and rotational working arrangements may be required. Employees may also face greater exposure to layoffs when customer contracts are not renewed.
The difference is therefore not limited to hourly pay. Integrated airlines generally offer a career structure designed to retain pilots over the long term. ACMI employment packages are often more transactional, appealing to particular lifestyle preferences or faster career progression but potentially offering fewer incentives for experienced pilots to remain throughout their careers.
Recruitment and Retention: The Increasing Challenge for ACMI Operators
Such pay disparities have a direct impact on pilots’ employment decisions.
Integrated carriers attract candidates who want lifetime earnings, retirement security and predictable career progression. They remain a recruiting attraction even in times of lower external hiring, such as recent periods when there were internal pilot surpluses or fleet transitions at both FedEx and UPS.
On the face of it, outsourcing aircraft capacity seems to broaden the cargo industry’s operational resources. But this diversification may be less important than it looks.
There is a pool of qualified pilots that several ACMI operators are competing for. This means capacity can be shared between several aircraft operators, but concentrated around a limited number of available professionals.
As the compensation gap grows, it becomes more difficult to recruit and retain experienced captains. Operators may then be faced with higher training costs and greater reliance on less experienced crews or temporary workforce arrangements.
The effects are visible already.
Atlas Air pilots filed approximately 310 departures in one year during labor negotiations, or about 12% of the company's pilot ranks. That speaks to the potential scale of the retention challenges facing companies whose operating models rely on access to qualified flight crews.
The same pressure influences the stability of the workforce during periods of high demand. Better pay and benefits can help integrated carriers reduce voluntary turnover, but ACMI operators are at greater risk of losing staff when they need their planes most.
This is likely an expensive cycle. Higher labor costs are pressuring the economics of outsourced capacity and could ultimately result in higher ACMI rates or a reduction in aircraft availability for customers.
While industry-wide concerns about a pilot shortage have faded, experienced widebody pilots are still a rare and sought-after commodity, especially among carriers flying international freighter fleets.
Hence the cargo industry is not competing in one, homogenous labor market. Different employment models appeal to different sections of the pilot workforce.
They are also recruited from a range of professional backgrounds. Military aviators, passenger airline pilots, regional airline crews, and corporate flight departments all contribute personnel to the cargo sector.
Both FedEx and UPS have recruitment programs for ex-military pilots transitioning into commercial aviation, helping them to get more experienced pilots.
Negotiations in the labor area are changing the competitive landscape
Collective bargaining agreement structure and timing add another layer of competition for pilots.
FedEx’s 2026 deal has changed compensation expectations throughout the cargo aviation industry. Large wage changes at integrated carriers are seldom isolated occurrences. They influence hiring strategies, retention decisions and bargaining demands throughout the industry.
UPS pilots are now bargaining under an older contract, but with the benchmark set by the FedEx settlement. Since late 2025 a mediator has been involved.
ACMI operators have a different negotiation environment. A lot of them are represented by the Teamsters or independent pilot unions and are under agreements that have shorter or more frequent bargaining cycles.
This can make them particularly susceptible to competitive pressure from larger, integrated carriers.
Collective bargaining agreement timelines
The differences between the major operators are also reflected in their respective contract dates.
Carrier | Contract Amendable Date |
|---|---|
FedEx | December 2030 |
UPS | September 2025 (Currently in mediation) |
ABX Air | January 2030 |
Atlas Air | September 2026 |
ATI | April 2030 |
Sources: Carriers, unions and vectorstohired.com.
Wage differences can put strain on either end of the labor market.
Lower-paying operators may have to offer big increases to close the gap, he said. Meanwhile, integrated carriers must absorb the cost of offering premium compensation packages.
Long negotiations and perceived inequalities can also affect employees’ morale, productivity and operational discipline. In air cargo, where reliable service and precise timing are important, these risks are especially salient.
Thus, labor negotiations should not be considered as negotiations on employment costs alone. They are also discussions of future capacity.
operators may find it difficult to recruit and retain staff, which could affect their ability to provide reliable aircraft capacity, unless they can negotiate competitive agreements.
Implications for Air Cargo Network Resilience
The fallout from unstable workforces reaches far beyond the airlines themselves.
FedEx and UPS have freighter fleets that provide a relatively reliable backbone for cargo networks, if they have enough pilots. However, ACMI operators offer the additional flexibility to meet seasonal demand peaks, aircraft-on-ground situations and new market opportunities.
“This is particularly useful as it allows customers to grow their operations without the investment and long-term overhead of purchasing additional aircraft.”
But this flexibility is becoming harder to guaranty when ACMI providers are struggling to recruit and retain enough pilots.
This could mean tighter aircraft availability, higher spot rates and fewer contingency options for customers, just when more capacity is most valuable.
The implications go beyond pilot staffing. Industry watchers are increasingly pointing to the availability of labor as a potential limiting factor to airfreight performance. This includes air traffic controllers and other skilled workers whose work has a direct impact on operational continuity.
The reserve capacity provided by ACMI operators is crucial for shippers during peak shipping seasons, severe weather events, aircraft groundings or geopolitical disruptions.
If labor shortages mean these companies cannot get their aircraft airborne, the industry loses one of its most important ways of absorbing operational shocks.
Thus the durability of the network is not only a function of how many freighters are available. It depends also on the number of qualified professionals who can operate them.
In this context, pilot pay has effectively become a capacity policy.
The recent deal with FedEx is an example of how investing in the workforce can help with retention, operational continuity and network stability. At the same time, the ACMI providers must make sure that employment conditions are attractive enough to provide the flexibility they offer their customers.
An operator that is too far behind the market in compensation risks becoming a less reliable source for outsourced lift.
You can lease or buy aircraft but it is much harder to find qualified and experienced pilots.
Thus, compensation trends may be an early indicator of future capacity constraints in the North American cargo market.
The best networks will be those where a combination of integrated airlines and outsourced operators can attract and retain crews as needed by their respective business models.
The Road Ahead: Aircraft Ownership Is No Longer the Whole Story
The compensation divide between integrated carriers and ACMI providers is unlikely to disappear in the near future.
Large integrated airlines will continue using their scale and network economics to finance premium employment packages. ACMI operators, meanwhile, are expected to maintain their competitive position through operational flexibility, aircraft utilization and employment arrangements that offer specific lifestyle or career advantages.
The challenge will be ensuring that these different business models remain sufficiently attractive to the pilots they need.
Operators that recognize compensation as a strategic investment rather than simply an operating expense will be better positioned to maintain reliable services through future demand cycles and periods of disruption.
For air cargo professionals, the underlying message is straightforward: the ability to move freight reliably starts with the ability to recruit and retain the people flying the aircraft.
The modern cargo industry increasingly separates aircraft ownership, commercial network control and workforce management. As ACMI providers take on a larger share of outsourced freighter operations, access to qualified crews could become more important than access to aircraft themselves.
The industry traditionally measures capacity through freighter numbers, block hours and available payload tonnes. Increasingly, however, another indicator deserves equal attention: the ability to keep aircraft properly staffed and consistently operational.
Ultimately, the companies with the strongest control over air cargo capacity may not be those owning the largest fleets, but those most successful in attracting, developing and retaining the pilots needed to keep them flying.
Industry event announcement: Cargo Facts LATAM 2027, an event for stakeholders across Latin America, is scheduled for February 10–12, 2027, at the Marquis Reforma in Mexico City. Early-bird registration is available until January 8.



