An independent investigation into allegations of a US$250 million bribe in connection with the sinking of the X-Press Pearl has found no evidence to support claims that the vessel owners or the London P&I Club tried to influence Sri Lankan authorities over compensation proceedings.

The investigation, led by Sigma7 Business Intelligence and commissioned by the London P&I Club, looked into claims that the Club or the vessel owner, X-Press Feeders, had paid US$250 million to influence the Sri Lankan government’s efforts to seek compensation for the environmental damage caused by the maritime disaster.

The container ship caught fire in May 2021 and sank off the coast of Sri Lanka on June 2. The cargo was plastic pellets, commonly referred to as nurdles, which were released into the marine environment. The incident later became the subject of a US$1 billion compensation claim by Sri Lankan authorities over environmental damage.

Where the $250M claim originated

When the bribery allegations were made public in April 2023, there were several lawsuits relating to the disaster ongoing.

Wijeyadasa Rajapakshe, the then Minister of Justice, Prison Affairs and Constitutional Reforms of Sri Lanka, said he had received information that a bribe of US$250 million had been paid to influence the compensation process pursued by the government.

The allegation then snowballed beyond the initial claim, being repeated in Parliament, reported in the media and raised in proceedings before Sri Lanka's Supreme Court.

Sigma7 was tasked to investigate the source of the allegation, the evidence supporting it and the credibility of the alleged financial transactions.

Its investigation found no evidence to support claims that either the London P&I Club or the owners of the X-Press Pearl had made the alleged payment. The company also identified “significant gaps and inconsistencies” in the information used to justify the charge.

Major discrepancies found in investigation

One of the main findings was the alleged source of the accusation. The claim was said to have originated from an anonymous Whatsapp message, but the original message, the sender’s telephone number or the person behind it have never been identified.

The financial information also casts a shadow of doubt on the credibility of the allegation.

The alleged US$250 million payment was initially reported to have been lodged into a NatWest bank account in the United Kingdom. But the story in the various versions of the accusation did not tally.

Sigma7 also said a transfer of this size would have been subject to scrutiny under the UK’s anti-money laundering controls.

It was then moved out of the NatWest account and into another account in the Bahamas, the allegation alleged. But no verifiable banking information was provided to substantiate the existence or location of the alleged transaction.

The investigation also showed changes in the identity of the person who was said to be the intermediary or the recipient of the funds.

Another important aspect related to Ajith Mannapperuma, Member of Parliament, who had first said that he had received the allegation through WhatsApp. He said he did not believe the first message because he could not find any evidence to back up what was being said.

Together, these findings led Sigma7 to conclude that there was no evidence of the alleged bribery.

Former senior British police officer backs the findings

Richard Walton, former Head of the Metropolitan Police's Counter Terrorism Command, reviewed Sigma7's investigation and the methodology supporting its conclusions.

He expressed support for the report's central finding, stating that there was no credible evidence that the London P&I Club or X-Press Feeders, owners of the X-Press Pearl, had paid a US$250 million bribe to influence compensation proceedings arising from the vessel's sinking.

Walton also highlighted what he considered fundamental weaknesses in the original accusation, particularly the inconsistencies surrounding the alleged financial transfers.

He pointed to the demonstrably flawed bank account details, conflicting accounts of the identity of the alleged recipient and discrepancies concerning the purported destination of the funds.

In his assessment, these contradictions go beyond a simple absence of supporting documentation and significantly undermine the credibility of the original claims.

London P&I welcomes the independent review

The London P&I Club, which commissioned the investigation on behalf of the X-Press Pearl owners, welcomed the publication of Sigma7's findings.

In its statement, the Club said the investigation had been commissioned specifically to address what it described as a very serious accusation and that it appreciated the independent examination of the claims.

It also emphasised that the report identified significant inconsistencies between the different versions of the alleged bribery, including repeated changes in the identity of the purported recipient and discrepancies in the banking information.

The Club reiterated the investigation's principal conclusion: no evidence had been found to support the allegation that a US$250 million bribe was paid in connection with the compensation proceedings following the X-Press Pearl disaster.