The global ship recycling market remains in troubled waters with no signs of recovery in sight despite changing trends in the freight sector. Tanker rates have fallen from record highs but stronger dry bulk rates are a welcome boost for vessel owners, meaning there is less incentive to scrap older ships.

The supply of vessels for recycling remains tight and transactions low as the freight markets are relatively firm.

Recyclers across the Indian subcontinent are also facing tough conditions. Bangladesh continues to be the leading ship-breaking destination in the region, but the falling value of the Bangladeshi taka is making purchases more expensive just as steel prices are falling.

Weakness in domestic demand is also weighing on the market. The local steel market has been hurt by the slowdown in public construction activity because government consumption is a much smaller part of the overall demand. Wirana, one of the world’s largest buyers of end-of-life vessels, said Bangladesh Government’s share of steel consumption has sharply come down from 60 per cent to 20 per cent.

Meanwhile, Pakistan’s recycling market remains relatively stable. In terms of market activity, however, it trails behind Bangladesh, and with shipping markets currently strong, it is not easy to find attractive vessels for demolition.

But top cash buyer GMS believes Gadani still has the right foundations to respond when the right opportunities come along. The Pakistani shipbreaking hub is well-placed to profit from more attractive vessels when they come along, thanks to its infrastructure, buying power and continued interest in the recycling business.

In addition to these market pressures, the industry has suffered another blow to its access to European-owned vessels. The European Parliament’s Committee on the Environment, Climate and Food Safety has voted against a motion that would have allowed two Indian ship recycling facilities to accept end-of-life vessels owned by European Union-based companies.

The vote effectively blocked Shree Ram Vessel Scrap and YSI Recyclers from gaining approval. The vote was 48 members against the motion, 26 in favor and five abstaining.

Following inspections, the two Indian yards had been given the green light by the European Commission. But their inclusion on the list of certified recycling facilities was challenged on the basis that they use beaching practices, a form of ship breaking in which ships at the end of their life are run aground on beaches and then dismantled.

Eventually the committee in parliament sided with the objection and the two facilities were removed from the European ship recycling market.

This is happening at a time when there is a serious shortage of available recycling capacity in the global shipping industry. Industry experts warn that the absence of ship-scrapping facilities could have serious consequences for the industry if it is not addressed, especially as the need to recycle older ships grows.